This archive report was first published on 27 October 2019.
Dr. Tatu Kamau, a medical doctor with 31 years of experience, has sparked a fresh controversy over female genital mutilation (FGM) in Kenya. In a recent court case, Dr. Kamau argued that FGM is beneficial when performed by medical professionals, citing its ability to eliminate harm and promote fertility.
The debate has reignited a decades-long debate over the practice, which was banned by the government in 2011. The government's main concern is that if the law criminalizing FGM is declared unconstitutional, young girls will be exposed to harm and early marriages.
Dr. Kamau's argument is supported by a former police officer, Joseph Kiplagat arap Koech, who believes that Kenyan women should be allowed to undergo FGM as it liberates them. However, the government and medical experts argue that FGM has no benefits and should remain illegal.
The case has brought back memories of a similar controversy in 1929, when the church demanded that its followers in Mt. Kenya stop practicing FGM. The debate has also highlighted the cultural significance of FGM, with Dr. Kamau arguing that it is a custom that should be allowed for willing adult women.
According to the country's policy on FGM, released in July 2018, the highest number of girls likely to undergo the cut are aged between 12 and 18. The case is now before the High Court, with judges considering the scientific evidence presented by medical experts and Dr. Kamau's argument that FGM is beneficial when performed by medical professionals.
