The Labour Court has rejected a legal effort by Kenyan tea pickers to obtain medical records from James Finlay Kenya, ruling the case lacked merit due to prior litigation. The petition, filed by seven workers, sought access to health data to support claims in a UK court over alleged workplace injuries.
Previous Litigation Barred New Claims ¶
Justice Hellen Wasilwa dismissed the case, noting a similar 2019 petition that is now under appeal at the Court of Appeal. She ruled the workers had improperly reused a legal process, as the 2019 court had already denied access to the requested information. "The petitioners are seeking similar information in the current petition which is already barred by the Hon. Judge in Petition 30 of 2019," the judge stated.
UK Court Proceedings and Workplace Allegations ¶
The workers allege they suffered physical and psychological harm from hazardous conditions at Finlay’s Kericho tea estates. They are pursuing £15,000 ($190,000) each in compensation through the All Scotland Sheriff Personal Injury Court. A 2018 Scottish court order initially mandated production of workplace data, later amended to allow site inspections of Finlay’s Kapsongoi, Kaporet, Marinyn, and Tiluet tea factories.
Finlay, a Glasgow-based firm established in the 18th century, operates multiple Kenyan tea estates. The workers argued access to medical records was essential to uphold their constitutional right to health, but the Labour Court found their request redundant given existing legal proceedings.