The Labour Court has ruled that the Salaries and Remunerations Commission (SRC) lacks authority to set pay increases for National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF) workers during collective bargaining, rejecting its 2017-2020 proposed 6% annual raise.
Legal Basis for Ruling ¶
Justice Maureen Onyango emphasized that while SRC can advise NHIF, its recommendations cannot override negotiated agreements. The court cited the 1949 ILO Convention No. 98 on collective bargaining rights and Article 2(6) of Kenya's Constitution, calling SRC's binding demands unconstitutional.
Pay Dispute Context ¶
The Kenya Union of Commercial Food and Allied Workers (KUCFAW) had sought 8% increases in 2017-2018, 10% in 2019, and 12% in 2020. NHIF initially accepted these terms but later attempted to impose SRC's 6% proposal, prompting the legal challenge.
Financial Implications ¶
Unionisable workers numbered 1,175 in the last audited report, costing NHIF Sh2.3 billion in basic salaries. The insurer has reduced staff to 800, cutting 600 positions since 2017 through termination benefits totaling Sh1.1 billion.
Operational Strains ¶
NHIF faces financial pressure from recent regulatory changes limiting penalties for late contributions and extending waiting periods for voluntary members. A 2019 Hefrep report highlighted administrative costs, with staff expenses comprising over 50% of 2017/18 expenses.
Leadership Vacuum ¶
The agency has lacked a permanent chief executive since 2018, when former CEO Geoffrey Mwangi and acting finance director Wilbert Kurgat were placed on compulsory leave amid investigations into billions in lost funds. Nicodemus Odongo has led as acting director since then.